Rows & Stitches
Your gauge is off. Which needle size do you change to?
You knit the swatch, you measured it, and the number is wrong. The pattern wants 20 stitches to 4 inches and you got 22. Now you have to decide which way to move, and the answer feels backwards to a lot of people the first time they meet it, because more stitches sounds like more fabric when it actually means less.
This page gives the rule, the arithmetic for working out how much your size is really off by, and the needle size charts you need to act on it. The conversion tables come from the Craft Yarn Council, which is the body that publishes the yarn and needle standards most English-language patterns are written against.
Count the stitches across 4 inches of a blocked swatch. More stitches than the pattern asks for means your fabric is too tight, so move up to a larger needle. Fewer stitches means it is too loose, so move down to a smaller one. Millimetres are the real measurement. US and old UK numbers are only labels printed on the packet.
The rule, in the words of the people who publish the standard
The Craft Yarn Council states it on its hooks and needles page without any hedging: if your swatch is larger than the pattern gauge, redo a swatch using a smaller hook or needle, and if your gauge swatch is too small, redo it using a larger hook or needle to obtain the gauge indicated in the pattern.
That is phrased in terms of the size of the swatch. Most people count stitches instead, which flips the wording round, so here is the same rule both ways. It is one rule, not two.
- Too many stitches in 4 inches means each stitch is small, the fabric is tight, and you go up to a larger needle.
- Too few stitches in 4 inches means each stitch is big, the fabric is loose, and you go down to a smaller needle.
- A swatch that came out wider than 4 inches at the pattern stitch count is the same thing as too few stitches, so again, smaller needle.
- A swatch that came out narrower is the same thing as too many stitches, so larger needle.
Measure the swatch properly first, or you are solving the wrong problem
A lot of gauge that looks wrong is just badly measured. Before you change anything, make sure the number you are reacting to is real.
Brooklyn Tweed's swatching guide is specific about the method, and the points below follow it. The short version is that the swatch has to be bigger than the measurement, finished the way the garment will be finished, and measured with something that does not stretch.
- Cast on enough for a 6 or 8 inch square. A generous swatch keeps edge stitches out of your 4 inch measurement.
- Do not measure before the swatch is bound off.
- Block it the same way you will block the finished garment, by steaming or wet blocking.
- If you can, let the fabric relax for 12 to 24 hours after drying or unpinning before taking the final measurement.
- Use a rigid ruler. Flexible tape measures stretch over time.
- Count the stitches within 4 inches across the centre of the fabric, then turn the ruler 90 degrees for the row count.
How wrong is it, actually?
Before you reach for a different needle, work out what the mismatch costs you in inches. Sometimes it is nothing worth chasing, and sometimes a gauge that is only two stitches out ruins the garment.
The arithmetic is simple division. Your stitches per inch is your 4 inch count divided by 4. The pattern casts on a fixed number of stitches, so the width you get is that stitch count divided by your stitches per inch.
The table works through a pattern written at 20 stitches to 4 inches for a 40 inch chest, which means it has you cast on 200 stitches. Every row below is the same 200 stitches, worked at a different gauge.
| Your gauge (sts / 4 in) | Sts per inch | 200 sts measures | Against a 40 in target |
|---|---|---|---|
| 18 | 4.50 | 44.4 in | 4.4 in too wide |
| 19 | 4.75 | 42.1 in | 2.1 in too wide |
| 20 | 5.00 | 40.0 in | on target |
| 21 | 5.25 | 38.1 in | 1.9 in too narrow |
| 22 | 5.50 | 36.4 in | 3.6 in too narrow |
Which needle is one size up?
This is where it gets messy, because a US size is a label and a millimetre is a measurement. The Craft Yarn Council says so plainly: letter and number sizing vary from company to company, so rely on the package millimetre sizing, which is an accurate measurement.
The chart below is the Craft Yarn Council's knitting needle size range in full. Read down the millimetre column to step up or down. Going up one step from 4 mm means 4.25 mm if your brand makes one, otherwise 4.5 mm.
| Metric | US | Metric | US |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1.50 mm | 000 | 5.25 mm | 9 |
| 1.75 mm | 00 | 5.50 mm | 9 |
| 2 mm | 0 | 5.75 mm | 10 |
| 2.25 mm | 1 | 6 mm | 10 |
| 2.75 mm | 2 | 6.50 mm | 10 1/2 |
| 3 mm | no US size | 7 mm | no US size |
| 3.125 mm | 3 | 8 mm | 11 |
| 3.25 mm | 3 | 9 mm | 13 |
| 3.50 mm | 4 | 10 mm | 15 |
| 3.75 mm | 5 | 12.50 mm | 17 |
| 4 mm | 6 | 12.75 mm | 17 |
| 4.25 mm | 6 | 15 mm | 19 |
| 4.50 mm | 7 | 19 mm | 35 |
| 5 mm | 8 | 25 mm | 50 |
Why the US numbers cannot be trusted on their own
Look along that chart and the problem shows itself. Several US numbers cover two different diameters, and two common diameters have no US number at all.
This is the practical reason to think in millimetres. Two needles both labelled US 6 can be 4 mm and 4.25 mm, a real difference in the fabric, and moving from a US 9 to a US 10 might be a jump of 0.25 mm or 0.5 mm depending on which needles you happen to own.
- US 3 is both 3.125 mm and 3.25 mm.
- US 6 is both 4 mm and 4.25 mm.
- US 9 is both 5.25 mm and 5.50 mm.
- US 10 is both 5.75 mm and 6 mm.
- US 17 is both 12.50 mm and 12.75 mm.
- 3 mm and 7 mm have no US number listed at all.
The old UK numbers, and why they count backwards
Older British and Canadian patterns use a third system, with numbers that get smaller as the needle gets bigger. There is a reason for that, and it is not knitting. Those numbers are Standard Wire Gauge, the wire sizing system fixed by Order of Council in 1883 and made a legal standard by the British Board of Trade on 1 March 1884. Wire gauges count down as the wire thickens, so knitting needles inherited the same backwards numbering.
The Craft Yarn Council does not publish UK equivalents, so the millimetre column below is the true SWG diameter for that gauge number, which is exact, paired with the nearest modern metric needle, which is a rounding. The US column is the Craft Yarn Council size for that metric needle. Note that BS 3737, the standard SWG was tied to, has since been withdrawn.
| Old UK no. | True SWG diameter | Nearest metric needle | US |
|---|---|---|---|
| 14 | 2.032 mm | 2 mm | 0 |
| 13 | 2.337 mm | 2.25 mm | 1 |
| 12 | 2.642 mm | 2.75 mm | 2 |
| 11 | 2.946 mm | 3 mm | no US size |
| 10 | 3.251 mm | 3.25 mm | 3 |
| 9 | 3.658 mm | 3.75 mm | 5 |
| 8 | 4.064 mm | 4 mm | 6 |
| 7 | 4.470 mm | 4.50 mm | 7 |
| 6 | 4.877 mm | 5 mm | 8 |
| 5 | 5.385 mm | 5.50 mm | 9 |
| 4 | 5.893 mm | 6 mm | 10 |
| 3 | 6.401 mm | 6.50 mm | 10 1/2 |
| 2 | 7.010 mm | 7 mm | no US size |
| 1 | 7.620 mm | 7.50 mm | no US size |
| 0 | 8.230 mm | 8 mm | 11 |
What the yarn weight tells you before you ever swatch
The Craft Yarn Council's Standard Yarn Weight System gives, for each category, both the usual gauge range and the needle range that normally produces it. If your pattern gauge sits far outside the range for the yarn you picked, no needle change is going to rescue it and the yarn is the problem.
The council labels these guidelines only, reflecting the most commonly used gauges and needle sizes for each category, not rules. Lace carries its own caveat: lace yarns are usually worked on larger needles to create openwork, so a gauge range is hard to pin down and you should always follow the gauge stated in your pattern.
| No. | Category | Knit gauge, sts to 4 in | Metric needle | US needle |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 0 | Lace | 33-40 | 1.5-2.25 mm | 000-1 |
| 1 | Super Fine | 27-32 | 2.25-3.25 mm | 1 to 3 |
| 2 | Fine | 23-26 | 3.25-3.75 mm | 3 to 5 |
| 3 | Light | 21-24 | 3.75-4.5 mm | 5 to 7 |
| 4 | Medium | 16-20 | 4.5-5.5 mm | 7 to 9 |
| 5 | Bulky | 12-15 | 5.5-8 mm | 9 to 11 |
| 6 | Super Bulky | 7-11 | 8-12.75 mm | 11 to 17 |
| 7 | Jumbo | 6 and fewer | 12.75 mm and larger | 17 and larger |
How many sizes should you move?
Knitters often repeat a figure for how much one needle size shifts gauge. Nothing in the Craft Yarn Council's standards, and nothing in the swatching guides checked while writing this page, puts a number on it, so this page will not give you one. It depends on the yarn, the stitch pattern and your own hands.
What you can do is read an indication off the council's own table. In the Medium category the needle range is 4.5 to 5.5 mm, a single millimetre, and the gauge range across that millimetre is 16 to 20 stitches, four stitches. That is a derivation from the published ranges rather than a measured rule, but it suggests the move you need is usually small and that a gap of four or five stitches is a bigger problem than one needle size.
So change by one step, swatch again, and measure again. If you are a long way out, say three or more stitches, expect to swatch more than twice, and consider whether the yarn weight is right for the pattern before you keep climbing the needle chart.
When a different needle is not the answer
Stitch gauge and row gauge do not always come right together, and some mismatches are not a size problem at all.
- Stitch gauge correct, row gauge wrong. Brooklyn Tweed suggests trying the same size in a different needle material, since surface grip changes tension.
- Swatched flat, knitting in the round. Many people work at a different tension in the round, so swatch the way you will work.
- Different yarn, same weight category. The council warns the weight system is not an interchangeability chart, and that two yarns in one category may still differ in hand and drape even at the same gauge.
- Crocheting, not knitting. The same up and down rule applies, and the council's hook chart runs 2.25 mm at B-1, 4 mm at G-6, 5 mm at H-8 and 6.50 mm at K-10 1/2.
- Steel crochet hooks. These are numbered the reverse way round, the higher the number the smaller the hook, so check you are reading the right chart.
Questions
My swatch has more stitches than the pattern. Bigger or smaller needle?
Bigger. More stitches in 4 inches means each stitch is smaller than the pattern expects, so you need a larger needle to open the fabric up. The Craft Yarn Council puts it the other way round, as a swatch that came out too small needing a larger needle, which is the same instruction.
How much does one needle size change the gauge?
No published standard gives a figure, and this page will not invent one, because it varies with yarn, stitch pattern and tension. As an indication only, the Craft Yarn Council's Medium category spans 4.5 to 5.5 mm against a gauge range of 16 to 20 stitches to 4 inches. Change one step, reswatch, and measure again.
Is a US 6 always 4 mm?
No. The Craft Yarn Council chart lists US 6 against both 4 mm and 4.25 mm. The council's own advice is to rely on the millimetre size on the packet, because letter and number sizing varies from company to company while millimetres are an actual measurement.
Why do old UK needle sizes get smaller as the needle gets bigger?
Because they are Standard Wire Gauge numbers, a wire sizing system fixed by Order of Council in 1883 and made a legal standard in Britain in 1884. Wire gauge numbers count down as the wire thickens. The knitting sizes simply inherited that. Old UK 8 is SWG 8, a true 4.064 mm, which is why it sits against a modern 4 mm needle.
Do I have to block the swatch before measuring?
If the garment will be blocked, yes, and in the same way. Brooklyn Tweed's guide says to block the swatch the same manner you will use for the finished garment, not to measure before it is bound off, and if possible to let it relax for 12 to 24 hours after drying before taking final measurements.
What if no needle gets me to gauge?
Check the yarn against the Craft Yarn Council weight categories. If the pattern gauge sits outside the usual range for that weight, the yarn is the mismatch rather than the needle. The council also warns that its weight system is not an interchangeability chart, so two yarns in the same category can still behave differently.
Sources: Craft Yarn Council, Hooks & Needles (https://www.craftyarncouncil.com/standards/hooks-and-needles) for the full knitting needle and crochet hook millimetre to US charts, for the instruction to rely on the package millimetre sizing because letter and number sizing varies from company to company, and for the rule that a swatch larger than pattern gauge needs a smaller needle and a swatch too small needs a larger one. Craft Yarn Council, Standard Yarn Weight System (https://www.craftyarncouncil.com/standards/yarn-weight-system) for the categories 0 to 7, the knit gauge ranges in stockinette to 4 inches, the recommended metric and US needle ranges, the guidelines-only caveat, the lace caveat and the note that steel hooks are numbered in reverse. Craft Yarn Council, Standards FAQs (https://www.craftyarncouncil.com/standards/faqs) for the weight system not being an interchangeability chart and for hand and drape differing between yarns at the same gauge. Brooklyn Tweed, Swatching 101 (https://brooklyntweed.com/pages/swatching-101) for the 6 to 8 inch swatch, blocking as for the finished garment, not measuring before bind off, the 12 to 24 hour rest, the rigid ruler, counting across the centre of the fabric, and trying a different needle material when row gauge alone is off. Standard wire gauge (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Standard_wire_gauge) for the SWG diameters in millimetres, the 1883 Order of Council, the Board of Trade legal standard of 1 March 1884 and the withdrawal of BS 3737. Not verified, and deliberately left out: no figure is given for how much one needle size changes gauge, because no source checked publishes one. The Craft Yarn Council does not publish old UK or Canadian needle equivalents, so the old UK table here pairs the exact SWG diameter with the nearest modern metric needle rather than quoting a knitting conversion chart, and those pairings are roundings, not standards. The worked example table of widths at different gauges is plain arithmetic on 200 stitches, not quoted from a source. The claim that many knitters work at a different tension in the round is given as a reason to swatch in the round, not as a measured effect.