Split Flap

How a split-flap display works, and where it came from

A split-flap board is one of the few pieces of public machinery most people have watched closely without ever being told how it works. The letters run forward in a blur, settle, and the row says something. Almost everything written about how that happens is written from the outside.

This page is built from documents instead: three patents filed by Solari of Udine between 1959 and 1966, the company's own dated history, a museum collection record, a corporate design archive, and the newspaper reporting around one named board being taken out of service. Where those sources disagree, which they do about one date, both are given. Where a popular explanation has no source behind it, it is left out and said so at the end.

A character is not chosen, it is counted to. Each column is a drum of hinged flaps that advances one indication at a time in one direction, and a stepping switch walks forward through contacts until it reaches the contact wired to the character you asked for, where a relay breaks the drive circuit. The clatter is the counting.

What is actually turning

One column of a board is one drum. Hinged plates hang off it, each printed with half of one character and half of the next, so that as the drum turns and a plate falls forward the lower half of one and the upper half of another meet at the centre line and read as a whole letter. Solari's patents call those plates pallets and blades rather than flaps: the 1966 drum patent speaks of "the drum carrying the pallets" that the viewer sees, and the 1961 board patent describes blade wheels in which "each blade carries at least one symbol on one face."

The stock of characters is the stock of plates. Fondazione Pirelli's description of the Cifra 5 clock, the first clock Gino Valle designed for the company, puts a number on a domestic example: a roller with 40 flaps, legible at 15 metres. A station board column carrying the full alphabet, the digits and some punctuation simply has a longer stack.

Advance is by whole steps. In the 1966 patent a pawl pivoted on a rocker plate engages a gear on the drum, and a pin travelling in an arcuate slot limits the swing so that, in the patent's words, to a maximum stroke of the pin "corresponds an advance" of exactly one indication. A pawl on a gear is a ratchet, so the drum goes forward and does not come back.

  • One character is two half-plates. The flap that just fell is still showing you the top of the character you are reading.
  • There is no shortcut. Nothing in these mechanisms selects a plate directly; the drum moves through the intervening positions.
  • Columns are modules. The 1961 patent mounts each wheel on a bracket carrying a multi-pole plug, so a column plugs in when it is pushed home, and the line cables run back to what it calls "the central control panel."
  • Noise is a by-product. The further the character you want sits from the one showing, the longer that column runs, which is why a whole board changing sounds like overlapping rhythms rather than one beat.

How the board knows where to stop

This is the part usually hand-waved, and it is the part Solari's 1959 British filing, Improvements relating to visual indicating assemblies, sets out plainly. The indicator is driven by what the patent calls a seeking switch: a solenoid whose every energisation advances a switch arm from one pair of contacts to the next, pulsed by a pair of slow-release relays that re-arm each other so the thing keeps stepping on its own.

Selection is wiring, not computation. A second bank of contacts on the same switch carries the contact for the indication you want, and when the arm arrives at it a relay is energised and opens its own contact in the solenoid's circuit. The drive stops because the current path has been broken at the position that was asked for.

The same patent also explains how a row of identical columns can be driven together: a master switch and two remote slave switches, with all three driving solenoids wired in series, and only the master carrying the selection contact. The slaves go where the master goes because they are stepped by the same pulses.

StageWhat happensSource for it
A character is requestedA contact in the switch's second bank, wired to that character's position, is selectedSolari, GB909094A (1959)
Drive startsThe driving solenoid is energised through a relay contactSolari, GB909094A
SteppingEach energisation advances the switch arm to the next pair of contacts; a second slow-release relay closes the circuit again after the first opensSolari, GB909094A
The drum followsA pawl on a rocker engages the drum gear; one full stroke corresponds to an advance of one indicationSolari, US3400598A (1965 priority)
ArrivalThe arm reaches the selected contact, a relay is energised and opens the contact in the solenoid circuitSolari, GB909094A
SettledDrive stops with the requested plate fallen and the half-plates alignedSolari, GB909094A
Many columns at onceMaster and slave switches with their solenoids in series; only the master has the selection contactSolari, GB909094A

Where it came from

The company is older than the mechanism by two centuries. Solari's own history dates the firm to 1725 in Pesariis, a village in Carnia in Friuli, making tower clocks, and the Art Institute of Chicago's collection record for the Cifra 3 clock likewise gives the manufacturer as Solari di Udine, founded 1725.

The split-flap part starts in 1948. Solari's history says that family disputes led the brothers Remigio and Fermo Solari to move to Udine and set up a new company, which came to dominate industrial clockmaking and public information displays "thanks to Remigio's invention of the famous split-flap display system." That is the company's own account of its own origin, which is worth saying out loud: it is the best-sourced claim available and it is not an independent one.

A patent record sits near that date without confirming it. The earliest Solari filing we found in the patent indexes is an application by Remigio Solari filed in 1950 and granted in 1954 for an electromechanical wall calendar clock. We could not read its description, so we are reporting that the filing exists with those dates and nothing about what it claims.

The named patents above all belong to Fermo Solari, filed between 1959 and 1966 as the displays were being industrialised and sold abroad.

What Solari introduced, and when

The design-prize record is the firmest part of the chronology, because the awards are dated events rather than recollections. Two Compasso d'Oro wins mark the two halves of the story: the domestic clock, then the public board.

  • 1956: the Cifra 5 clock, designed by Gino Valle (1923-2003), wins the Compasso d'Oro. Fondazione Pirelli describes it as the first of a family, with a roller of 40 flaps readable at 15 metres.
  • 1962: a second Compasso d'Oro, for the alphanumeric split-flap displays for airports and railway stations designed by Valle. Solari's awards page adds that they were adopted by Eero Saarinen for the TWA terminal at JFK.
  • 1964: Solari becomes part of the Pirelli Group.
  • 1965 or 1966: the Cifra 3, the firm's smallest direct-reading electric clock, with lettering by Massimo Vignelli. The Art Institute of Chicago dates the object to 1965; Fondazione Pirelli says 1966 and adds that it entered the Museum of Modern Art's permanent collection in New York in 1968. We could not open MoMA's own record to check, so both dates stand as given.
  • 1969: a Smau award for a split-flap clock for offices and interiors, again designed by Valle.
  • 1980: by Solari's account, contracts for large installations including Paris Saint-Lazare, Hong Kong Kai Tak, Milan Malpensa and Linate, JFK in New York, and airports in Brazil.

Why stations and airports used them

The sourced reason is legibility at a distance from a small unit, which is what both Compasso d'Oro citations reward: the 1962 prize was given for the aesthetic and functional qualities of the alphanumeric displays, and the clock in the same family was being described in terms of how far away it could be read.

The architecture of the system matters as much as the look of it. The 1961 patent's columns plug into brackets and report back to a central control panel over one cable per line, and the 1959 patent drives slave indicators from a master in series. A concourse full of boards showing the same thing, updated from one office, was the product being sold.

Two further reasons are repeated everywhere and we are not going to pretend to have sourced them. One is that the printed flaps need no backlight, which is true of a printed plate read by room light but is our observation of the mechanism, not a statement by anyone who specified these boards. The other is reliability, where we found no maintenance figures at all. The sound is likewise a consequence of ratchet stepping rather than a documented design goal.

Why one famous board went, and what replaced it

The honest version of the decline is specific rather than general, so here is one documented case. The Solari board in the great hall of Amtrak's 30th Street Station in Philadelphia was dismantled in late January 2019 and shipped to the Railroad Museum of Pennsylvania in Strasburg.

The reason given was accessibility, not fashion. Reporting in the Philadelphia Inquirer records that Amtrak had first planned removal, then said after public objection that it would consider renovating or rebuilding the board, and that the decision turned when disability rights advocates argued a split-flap board could not show real-time delay information for riders who cannot hear audio announcements. Amtrak has separately been reported as citing the inability to bring the board into ADA compliance.

What replaced it was a large digital sign above the information desk, switched on at 3am on 28 February 2019, which by that paper's account made 30th Street the last Amtrak station in the system to go digital. That is one station on one date. It is not evidence about every board anywhere, and we found no source that would support a sentence like that.

The maker moved the same way. Solari's own awards page lists a 2004 Compasso d'Oro special mention for an LED public information display at Venice Airport, and the company still builds split-flap displays as commissions, including, by its own account, boards for Starbucks Reserve Roasteries in 2018.

The clock relatives, and how they differ

Flip clocks and station boards get treated as two different inventions. They are one mechanism at different scales and with different character sets, which is why the same company won prizes for both.

FamilyWhat it showsHow it differs
Domestic flip clock, e.g. Cifra 5 (1956) and Cifra 3 (1965 or 1966)Hours and minutes onlyFew drums, digits only, a self-contained movement; the next minute is always the next flap, so it steps once and stops
Office and interior split-flap clock (Smau award, 1969)Time, at room scaleSame idea built for legibility across a room
Alphanumeric station and airport display (Compasso d'Oro, 1962)Destinations, times, platformsMany columns with long character stacks, driven from a central control panel over one cable per line
Software split-flap, including this appAnything you type, plus clocks and weatherNo drum, no stack order to obey; the step-by-step run is reproduced on purpose

What software can and cannot reproduce

Split Flap is an app. It draws the board and plays the sound, and it is worth being exact about which parts of the above it is imitating rather than doing.

What carries over is the behaviour you actually watch: characters running forward in order rather than cutting straight to the answer, columns finishing at different moments depending on how far they had to travel, and the flap sound arriving as each one lands. Those follow from the ratchet and the stepping switch, and they are the reason a board looks alive.

What does not carry over is everything physical. There is no drum, no fixed stack of plates, no mechanical limit on the character set, no paper to tear at the hinge and no motor to seize. A screen can show a character no printed stack contained, and it can change a thousand columns as cheaply as one. It also cannot fill a room the way a wall of real pallets does, and it is not pretending to.

Questions

How does a split-flap display choose a character?

It counts to it. In Solari's 1959 patent for visual indicating assemblies, a solenoid advances a switch arm one pair of contacts at a time, pulsed by two slow-release relays, while a second bank of contacts holds the contact wired to the character requested. When the arm reaches that contact a relay opens the solenoid circuit and the drive stops. Nothing addresses a flap directly, which is why the drum passes through the characters in between.

Why do split-flap boards clatter?

Because stepping is the selection method. The drum is advanced by a pawl on a gear, and Solari's 1966 patent sizes the stroke so that one full stroke corresponds to an advance of exactly one indication. A ratchet only goes forward, so reaching a character means running through the plates before it. A column with a long way to go runs longer, which is why a board changing at once sounds like several rhythms rather than one.

Who invented the split-flap display?

Solari of Udine credits Remigio Solari, in the company history that dates the move from Pesariis to Udine to 1948 and attributes the firm's rise to his invention of the split-flap display system. That is the company's own account rather than an independent one. The displays that were sold worldwide carry patents filed by his brother Fermo Solari between 1959 and 1966, and the industrial design of the clocks and boards is credited to the architect Gino Valle.

When was the Cifra 3 clock made?

Sources disagree by a year. The Art Institute of Chicago's collection record dates the Cifra 3 Synchron flip clock to 1965, designed by Gino Valle and manufactured by Solari di Udine. Fondazione Pirelli's account of the same clock says 1966, with lettering by Massimo Vignelli, and adds that it entered the Museum of Modern Art's permanent collection in 1968. We could not read MoMA's own record, so we give both years rather than picking one.

Why were split-flap boards replaced?

For the one case we can document, accessibility. The board at Amtrak's 30th Street Station in Philadelphia came down in late January 2019 after disability rights advocates argued it could not display real-time delay information for riders who cannot hear announcements, and a digital sign went live on 28 February 2019. Other boards elsewhere came down for their own reasons, and we found no source that justifies generalising from this one.

Is a flip clock the same thing as a departure board?

It is the same mechanism at a different scale. A flip clock is a few drums of digits with a self-contained movement; a station board is many columns with long alphanumeric stacks, wired back to a central control panel. Solari won design prizes for both, the Cifra 5 clock in 1956 and the alphanumeric airport and station displays in 1962.

Does the app use a real mechanism?

No. It is software that reproduces the behaviour: characters running forward in order, columns settling at different moments, and the flap sound as each one lands. There is no drum and no fixed set of printed plates, which is also why it can show things a real stack never held.

Sources, and which claim came from where. Solari SpA, company history (https://www.solari.it/en/?p=5910) for the 1725 founding at Pesariis, the 1948 move of Remigio and Fermo Solari to Udine and the company's attribution of the split-flap display system to Remigio, the 1964 entry into the Pirelli Group, and the 1980 installation contracts including Paris Saint-Lazare, Kai Tak, Malpensa, Linate, JFK and Brazil. Solari SpA, awards and recognitions (https://www.solari.it/en/?p=5920) for the 1956 Compasso d'Oro for the Cifra 5 designed by Gino Valle, the 1962 Compasso d'Oro for the alphanumeric split-flap displays for airports and railway stations and their adoption by Eero Saarinen at the TWA terminal, the 1969 Smau award for the office split-flap clock, the 2004 Compasso d'Oro special mention for an LED display at Venice Airport, and the 2018 Starbucks Reserve Roastery split-flap commissions. Fondazione Pirelli, Gino Valle, clocks, and the fusion of technology and design (https://www.fondazionepirelli.org/en/activities/exhibitions/gino-valle-clocks-and-the-fusion-of-technology-and-design/) for the Cifra 5 roller of 40 flaps legible at 15 metres, the Cifra 3 dated 1966 with lettering by Massimo Vignelli, and its entry into MoMA's permanent collection in 1968. Art Institute of Chicago, collection record for the Cifra 3 Synchron Flip Clock (https://www.artic.edu/artworks/251703/cifra-3-synchron-flip-clock, read through https://api.artic.edu/api/v1/artworks/251703) for the 1965 date, Gino Valle's dates of 1923 to 2003, and Solari di Udine founded 1725. Fermo Solari and Solari & C. SpA, GB909094A, Improvements relating to visual indicating assemblies, filed 29 June 1959 (https://patents.google.com/patent/GB909094A/en) for the seeking switch, the driving solenoid advancing the arm one pair of contacts per energisation, the two slow-release relays, the selected contact in the second bank energising a relay that opens the solenoid circuit, and the master and slave switches with solenoids in series. Fermo Solari and Solari & C. Udine SpA, US3400598A, Device for controlling the advance of drums in a display drum apparatus, Italian priority 9 August 1965, granted 10 September 1968 (https://patents.google.com/patent/US3400598A/en) for the drum carrying the pallets, the pawls on a rocker plate engaging the drum gears, and the stroke sized so that a maximum stroke corresponds to an advance of one indication. Fermo Solari and Solari SpA, US3190020A, filed 20 November 1961, granted 22 June 1965 (https://patents.google.com/patent/US3190020A/en) for the blade wheels in which each blade carries at least one symbol on one face, the brackets with multi-pole plugs, and the line cables running to the central control panel. The Philadelphia Inquirer, Amtrak's new digital sign at 30th St. Station is up and running, 27 February 2019 (https://www.inquirer.com/news/amtrak-flipboard-th-street-station-sign-digital-20190228.html) for the removal of the Solari board about a month earlier, the disability rights argument about real-time delay information for riders who cannot hear announcements, the digital sign going live at 3am on 28 February 2019, 30th Street being the last Amtrak station to go digital, and the board being shipped to the Railroad Museum of Pennsylvania. The further detail that Amtrak cited inability to bring the board into ADA compliance comes from contemporary local news reporting rather than from a statement we read in full, and is attributed as reported. Cut as unconfirmed: that split-flap boards were chosen because they need no backlight, which is a property of a printed plate rather than a sourced procurement reason, and is labelled as our observation on the page; that they were chosen or kept for reliability, since we found no maintenance or failure figures; that the sound was a design goal rather than a by-product; any claim that split-flap boards in general were replaced by LED or LCD displays on any particular timetable, since we have one named station on one date; the frequently repeated 1957 patent date for the Cifra 5, which we could not verify at source; and anything about what Remigio Solari's 1950 filing for an electromechanical wall calendar clock, granted in 1954, actually claims, since only its bibliographic record was readable. The description of each character as two half-plates meeting at a centre line is drawn from the patents' drum-and-pallet language and from the clock descriptions above rather than from a single quotable sentence.

Watch it run: the free split-flap message maker

Get Split Flap on the App Store

More about Split Flap ยท Contact us